1 of 3
1
#d09 Detroit 2009 Project
Posted: 23 December 2008 03:48 PM   [ Ignore ]
Administrator
Avatar
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  1567
Joined  2006-09-25

Master List of Resources from Autonomy Without Tears:
http://autonomywotears.blogspot.com/2009/01/d09-detroit-09-resource-list.html

Started on El Twitter:
http://search.twitter.com/search?q=#d09

Moved to Pizza SEO:
http://pizzaseo.blogspot.com/2008/12/world-design-party-d09-detroit-2009.html

Response from Klintron @ Technoccult:
http://www.technoccult.com/archives/2008/12/21/rebuilding-detroit/

I disagree with comment about first collecting standards and practices then starting franchises. The way to make these things work isn’t to get everyone to sign-on to one single experiment in one location. It’s to get a lot of concurrent experiments going and sharing information. Not everyone can move to Detroit or is willing to. Other alternatives suggested include Baffalo, NY and St. Louis, MO. I’d have to add Yakima, WA to the list as well.

Response from Jon Storvick @Autonomy Without Tears:
http://autonomywotears.blogspot.com/2008/12/detroit-09-reclaiming-cities-d09.html

More Background:

Acres of barren blocks offer chance to reinvent Detroit
http://www.cityfarmer.info/acres-of-barren-blocks-offer-chance-to-reinvent-detroit/

GM’s Bust Turns Detroit Into Urban Prairie of Vacant-Lot Farms
http://www.cityfarmer.info/gms-bust-turns-detroit-into-urban-prairie-of-vacant-lot-farms/

Ford Motor Company Gives $100,000 to ‘SEED Wayne’
http://www.cityfarmer.info/ford-motor-company-gives-100000-to-seed-wayne/

Profile
 
 
Posted: 23 December 2008 08:04 PM   [ Ignore ]   [ # 1 ]
Member
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  283
Joined  2007-05-11

I’d say the biggest dynamic is the human one. And by human I don’t mean the city officials. What will the people of the area think of this. How can you get them on your side and helping you? Will they see a bunch of white boys and/or suburbanites running around an area their brethren abandoned a couple decades back trying to make it look nice again(and why would they want it to look nice again)? And how will that make them feel, insulted or appreciative? Will they feel like your trying to show them up or help them out.

Such a tricky scenario.

Profile
 
 
Posted: 24 December 2008 02:56 AM   [ Ignore ]   [ # 2 ]
Administrator
Avatar
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  1567
Joined  2006-09-25

Agreed, but I think the most proven strategy in any environment like that is engagement and heavy gifting.  If we’re not engaging, training and employing our neighbors we’re not even going to last a year there...or anywhere else we attempted this kind of intervention at.

I’m up early this morning thinking over the numbers on Vermont.  What really interests me about this project recently is the template it will provide.  I’d like to see people doing mental exercises like this, no matter where they live, and talking about the results in local groups. 

It’s also got me thinking that World Design Parties might be stronger experiences if they were localized.  Perhaps that would be a good opening gag: “Welcome to the World Design Party.  First up, you cannot possibly understand the world, which is far too complex a system for a human brain to grasp in any meaningful way.  The best we can possibly hope for is an accurate picture of your current environment...”

Profile
 
 
Posted: 24 December 2008 09:25 AM   [ Ignore ]   [ # 3 ]
Administrator
Avatar
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  1567
Joined  2006-09-25

Christmas Eve Roundup @ Pizza SEO:
http://pizzaseo.blogspot.com/2008/12/d09-world-design-xmas-eve.html

Profile
 
 
Posted: 24 December 2008 11:51 AM   [ Ignore ]   [ # 4 ]
Member
Avatar
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  215
Joined  2007-06-03

-

Profile
 
 
Posted: 25 December 2008 05:12 PM   [ Ignore ]   [ # 5 ]
Administrator
Avatar
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  1567
Joined  2006-09-25

Yes, mike, that asbestos link was absolutely helpful, thank you.

Profile
 
 
Posted: 26 December 2008 11:26 AM   [ Ignore ]   [ # 6 ]
Member
Avatar
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  215
Joined  2007-06-03

-

Profile
 
 
Posted: 28 December 2008 12:53 AM   [ Ignore ]   [ # 7 ]
Member
Avatar
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  215
Joined  2007-06-03

-

Profile
 
 
Posted: 28 December 2008 11:45 AM   [ Ignore ]   [ # 8 ]
Member
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  70
Joined  2007-05-27
harflimon - 23 December 2008 08:04 PM

I’d say the biggest dynamic is the human one. And by human I don’t mean the city officials. What will the people of the area think of this. How can you get them on your side and helping you? Will they see a bunch of white boys and/or suburbanites running around an area their brethren abandoned a couple decades back trying to make it look nice again(and why would they want it to look nice again)? And how will that make them feel, insulted or appreciative? Will they feel like your trying to show them up or help them out.

Such a tricky scenario.

Yes, it seems that gentrification often results in residents pissed off at the new arrivals. You would probably need an ‘inside man’ to pull this off. If Iraq has taught us anything, even with the best of intentions, you cannot invade a community and expect them to be thankful. But if there are entire neighborhoods that are vacant, that problem goes away. (I doubt any such neighborhoods exist, they would probably be full of squatters.) But as the articles posted above suggest, Detroit is receptive to this line of thought so it should be feasible. I’d be tempted to join in since Detroit is only a hop, skip, jump and stone’s throw away. Somebody needs to upgrade our society and this project seems like a good attempt.

Profile
 
 
Posted: 29 December 2008 06:39 AM   [ Ignore ]   [ # 9 ]
Administrator
Avatar
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  1567
Joined  2006-09-25

^^Just to be clear: I’m not talking about rebuilding Detroit into a place that’s safe for white people to spend lots of credit and walk around with big shopping bags all day. That is literally dead.

Gentrification is when I buy up your block, tear down the houses, and build condos and stores to attract high-end consumers.  What I’m talking about is buying up your block, building everyone better homes, giving everyone a business, and moving to the next block.

The Iraq Invasion was a seizure of the commons.  US troops stole Iraq jobs and gave them to US contractors, stole Iraq infrastructure and gave it to the themselves, and shockingly, Iraq took offense.  I’m not talking about a military invasion or a hippie cracker paradise—show up, fix things, grow food, repeat.

Anyways, wanted to post this up:

All Things Considered, December 28, 2008 ·
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=98771280

“These days, stories about Detroit paint the American auto mecca as a city that’s lost its way. But for the remaining residents of the shrinking city, it’s also an urban frontier of the imagination.

For Robin Boyle, the chairman of planning and urban studies at Wayne State University, Detroit is an opportunity that is still looking for a solution.

“Detroit is a city which is part of a midcentury model of industrial and economic development that has moved on,” he says. It’s “quintessentially part of the 20th century, but certainly not part of the 21st century yet.”

“It may get there, but at present it has lost its raison d’etre,” Boyle continues. “In the old days, you made things here and you sold them outside our region.” That way of life has gone.

Plus, Detroit has lost more than half its population. Boyle describes it as a poor city still trying to support the infrastructure of a much larger one.

But Boyle, who’s been in the area for 17 years, wouldn’t think of leaving. He wants to be there when the city reinvents itself.

What Do You Do With The Rest Of A City?

Drive down the Chrysler Freeway, and you see wave after wave of rotted-out, burned-out homes. Much of the city is a mausoleum of enormous, empty auto plants that need new life.

“What do you do with more than a third of the rest of the city that’s no longer being used?” Boyle says no one has any clear ideas. “We’ve talked about urban planning, forestry — some cities are talking about opening up the old creeks and riverbeds that were covered over as the cities evolved in the 20th century.”

He says all these ideas should be given careful consideration, but rearranging a city is going to take new vision and a lot of political support.

Meanwhile, Detroit’s denizens are putting their own visions to work.

The Hope District

Over on the east side of Detroit is a group with a mission to reclaim a few blighted blocks in a commercial district. Their leader is Mike Wimberly, a tall, soft-spoken Detroit native who wields an economics degree with the spirit of a pioneer.

Wimberly bought up a few square city blocks and rechristened them the “Hope District.”

He and his group, “The Friends of Detroit and Tri-County,” planted gardens and scores of fruit trees in the area. They wired his 23,000-square-foot building, a former meat packing plant, for Internet access and now offer computer classes and training. The building also provides space for locally inspired projects such as the sewing group that made Wimberly’s corduroy hoodie.

Wimberly also encourages an “uptick in civility,” greeting everyone he sees on the streets politely and dedicating a part of his Hope District to conflict resolution for gangs. Murals decorate the sides of buildings, and everywhere there’s a strong sense of enterprise. “Think locally” — it’s Detroit’s new vibe.

His efforts may be having some effect. Recently, a real estate speculator fixed up a nearby dilapidated building after seeing Wimberly’s newly planted fruit tree groves.

Invincible And Starlet

Invincible, as she calls herself, is an Israeli-born hip-hop artist who grew up in nearby Ann Arbor and has lived in Detroit since 2002. She’s a 27-year-old community organizer who developed her own independent record label.

She works tirelessly at galvanizing residents and pushing back on city development where she doesn’t think residents are given a voice in the decisions affecting them. One of her pieces, named “Locusts,” describes her struggle:

Locusts and buzzards circle and hover above the
abandoned houses shattered windows with the crooked shutters
cross the street construct a cookie cutter condominium
lining Woodward its the prime meridian
enemies scheming on land seizures
pretend to be well meaning but stampede us
I know you not supposed to bite the hand that feeds ya
but its poisonous spread injustice like fungus/candida

Through her nonprofit group, Detroit Summer, Invincible has performed and recruited other singers, like Starlet Lee — who, at 20, has passionately thrown herself into organizing her neighborhood.

“We don’t have all the answers,” Lee says, “but we can come up with the answers ourselves, and not depend too much on external resources. We can create our own solutions, teach relevancy, give kids school credit for fixing up apartments, or learn math through building.”

Lee knows about starting over again. Foreclosure took the home she grew up in, scattering her family throughout the city. Invincible is her mentor, and she’s a master at adapting.

‘We Hope For Better Things’

The efforts of Detroit’s residents make it hard not to have hope for the city. Even so, Boyle fears another vision for Detroit, one he doesn’t want to realize.

“A place you pass by,” he says. “You can’t save every neighborhood.” He’s hoping the city can rebuild itself in the spirit of its motto: We Hope For Better Things; It Shall Rise From the Ashes.

That motto goes all the way back to 1805. Of course, everyone knows it’s not just about hope. But that’s a pretty good place to lay a foundation.”

Profile
 
 
Posted: 29 December 2008 06:52 AM   [ Ignore ]   [ # 10 ]
Administrator
Avatar
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  1567
Joined  2006-09-25

detroit_foreclosure_122608.gif

Profile
 
 
Posted: 29 December 2008 10:45 AM   [ Ignore ]   [ # 11 ]
Member
Avatar
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  215
Joined  2007-06-03

-

Profile
 
 
Posted: 06 January 2009 12:21 PM   [ Ignore ]   [ # 12 ]
Member
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  283
Joined  2007-05-11

Average home price $18,513 - Unemployment rate 21%

December 21, 2008

The Great Depression has reached Detroit. The average price of a home is now $18,513 and unemployment has reached 21%, and it’s expected to get worse. Detroit is facing a crisis of epic proportions that officially puts Detroit statistically (and real term) on par with the great depression. Many readers of Tribble Ad Agency are advertising centric.. and due to the rash of layoffs within all Detroit Advertising firms has put the city on the map for the wrong reasons.

It has become the center of all that is wrong with America… and nothing of what is right.

For example, the crime rate has fallen…. because of lack of targets within the city. Meaning there is nothing left to steal. In fact, even the criminals don’t want to leave jail.

Heard confirmed that some offenders, notably those without homes of their own, were now expressing reluctance to leave jail when their sentences were done.

Home values have plummeted to levels not seen in 1/2 a century… and the 21% unemployment has in some cases been projected to double within 12 months if the auto industry totally collapses.

To make matters even worse, Detroit has superseded New Orleans as the “worst city” in America…. but New Orleans had a Hurricane they could assign blame to… Detroit has no such natural disaster crutch.

“It’s a depression — not a recession,” McDuell said, with the authority of someone who has lived through both. “It will get worse before it gets better.”

It’s a man-made disaster.

Regarding a local food bank in Detroit that has seen record numbers of individuals entering the system:

“Many people are first-timers — they have no idea how to navigate the system, how to qualify for food stamps,” Wells said. “Last year, some were donors — now they’re clients.”

In short, last year they donated money into the system… now they are feeding from it because they themselves are in hard financial times.

Detroit needs a miracle, the chances of it showing a resurgence is slim to none in the current economic outlook.

EDIT Saturday December 27th — do to a flood of nearly 400 comments, commenting has been shut down for this thread. It’s not that we don’t like free speech… but speech that focuses on Religion, Color and other non-advertising issues are well beyond the scope of this news outlet for Advertising Agencies.

The reason we covered and researched this story was due to the rash of layoffs in Detroit within the Advertising Agency business, as many of these agencies depended on the Auto industry for their income.

We suggest any comments beyond the scope of advertising go to a free speech forum, such as sqlspace.com

Edit 2 : we re-enabled comments… please remember the scope of the site is Advertising.

http://www.tribbleagency.com/?p=3598

Profile
 
 
Posted: 06 January 2009 01:30 PM   [ Ignore ]   [ # 13 ]
Administrator
Avatar
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  1567
Joined  2006-09-25

I caught verbatim swipes from about a dozen different stories I’d already read in that text, interesting...definitely going to scope the comments, though, thanks for the heads-up

Profile
 
 
Posted: 06 January 2009 03:44 PM   [ Ignore ]   [ # 14 ]
Member
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  283
Joined  2007-05-11

Yea I’ve caught quite a few similarities in a few of the articles on Detroit that have been popping up on the internets. It seems Detroit has become the poster child for Decaying Post-Industrial Cities.

Profile
 
 
Posted: 07 January 2009 09:35 AM   [ Ignore ]   [ # 15 ]
Administrator
Avatar
RankRankRank
Total Posts:  1567
Joined  2006-09-25

http://www.slowfooddetroit.org/articles6.html

URBAN GARDENS ARE DETROIT’S HOPE
by Elizabeth Wahl

Detroit is a city in transition, now experiencing a period during which it must shed its industrial roots before moving forward toward a new economic structure, one that may finally begin to heal decades worth of structural wounds.  Yet its progression reaches far beyond the improvements slowly being made downtown.  A powerful example of this, and one which solidifies Detroit’s place as a true City of Hope, is the annual garden tour arranged by the Detroit Agricultural Network.  I, along with more than 300 others, climbed eagerly into old school buses on a city tour unlike any other, one that included lemon cucumbers and Indian mustard.

The tour revealed gems of growth among the thousands of currently vacant lots overgrown with weeds and invasive plants, and strewn with the rubble of disinvestment and disregard.  The number of community gardens in the city has grown to over 300, and is expected to keep climbing.  With little support from the city government, these numbers and the dedicated people behind them reveal a unique community of citizens around the expansive city reclaiming unused lands.  Whether cultivated as educational tools or as tools against food insecurity, these entrepreneurs are united in a powerful movement.

Heading my tour was the passionate Kristine Hahn, Michigan State University Garden Resource Program extension coordinator, and horticultural expert.  Hahn calls herself a “garden nerd” who specializes in urban farming as a resource for community building and mutual support.  As part of the myriad programs offered in conjunction with the Detroit Agriculture Network, Hahn teaches a 9-week program called Urban Roots, which focuses on the ins and outs of building an urban garden.  She cited the 113 community gardens (many of whom scrambled for a place on the tour), 18 school gardens, and 220 family gardens as evidence for the strength of the Detroit movement.

Sitting in the sunken seats, my diminutive self stared at the open blue sky above the abandoned homes and animated liquor stores.  As we hurtled onto the highway toward our first stop at Earth Works Garden, Hahn struggled to speak, but was eventually drowned out by the rush of air struggling to enter the barely cracked windows.

When only the rumbling of our bus remained, Hahn continued to laud the importance of self-sufficiency: “Urban gardens are one of the best tools we know to keep produce local and keep dollars in the community,” she said.  With the economy of Michigan crumbling, and with the continued loss of seemingly any work tied to the automobile industry, it was hardly necessary to continue.  Detroiters are hurting.  But, as Hahn expressed, “anyone can do it.”

Earth Works is an example of a highly productive farm, and of the innovations made by city gardeners.  Begun by Fransiscan monk Rick Samyn in coordination with the Capuchin Soup Kitchen, Earth Works farms just ¾ of an acre, but produces over 6,000 lbs of produce a year.  Much of the bounty is provided to the W.I.C. Project Fresh Program, a support system for low-income families who have no alternative access to fresh, organic produce.  Earth Works also works in conjunction with the Garden Resource Program to hold classes, distribute seeds and plants, and to give support to any who need it.  Located adjacent to the largest food bank in the city, the collective produces honey from 10 hives (five of which are on the roof of the bank), tends a hoop house to extend the growing season, cans jams, pickles beets, makes hand balm, and works with kids from throughout the city in its Growing Healthy Kids program to teach business skills and the value of sustainability.  You would never know any of this, however, from the humble demeanor of coordinator Patrick Crouch.

As we boarded the bus once again and continued hurtling through the city, Hahn intermittently shared facts about the largely unknown place of community gardening in the city.  Many people, including myself, were surprised to discover that the first urban gardening program grew out of the Great Depression during the 1890’s, in Detroit.  Then-mayor and future governor Hazen Pingree divvied up all vacant lands in the city, nearly 400 acres, for food production in support of the poor and underemployed.  Called P-Patches or Pingree’s Potato Patches as they consisted mainly of the hearty potato, these gardens undoubtedly saved numerous lives throughout one of only a few visible periods of widespread poverty in this country.  Pingree’s innovations were soon copied in cities all over America.

Those swathes of land gradually reverted to urbanity as the industrial importance of Detroit grew.  At the same time, as prosperity returned, our food systems became radically changed as we solidified the delineation of urban/rural, through the construction of suburbs, which would drastically alter our relationship with food.  As more and more workers moved to the cities, our understanding of where our food was coming from dwindled.

Slowly, however, our awareness is returning.  Worldwide movements are now dedicated to the simplistic knowledge that comes from a connection with the larger ecological systems of which we are a part.  But for Detroiters, the return to the soil came out of dire necessity rather than an attenuated return to the senses.  “One of our gardeners grew cotton just to prove that he could do it,” I overheard on our quick visit to Hawthorn Park Intergenerational Garden.  Much of the population here were once farmers in the South.  In the transition to city life, many retained their deftness with the trowel and the hoe, and retained the deeply rooted knowledge of how to care for living things.

Hahn and many others are working toward sharing the knowledge innate in all of us.  Another stop on our tour was to the Garden of Eden in the neighborhood of the historic Chene-Ferry Market.  Tended by former Hahn student and Peacemakers Ministry member Teresa Miller, the garden is an oasis in what Miller describes as a “grocery store desert.”

Exiting the bus, we were joined with a group of kids from the 4-H Community Center & Vandalia Community Gardens, where the gardeners and kids there practice a biointensive technique to maximize production.  “It’s just like the secret garden!,” I overheard one boy tell his friend.  The garden is impressively laid out in the second room of a burned out, roofless building, decorated, like many other city gardens, with murals painted by children.  Hahn poignantly expressed the value of the place.  “Peacemakers is a faith-based organization that ministers to pretty hard luck folks, “ she said.  “They really have done some miracles with turning some lives around.  You are taking an entire lot, which often is a magnet for crime, and turning it into a valuable green space, which cuts down on crime.  It’s the people walking by who end up talking to one another.  It’s not just about pretty flowers and vegetables (which is a great reason in and of itself), but has wide-ranging effects.”

“This is such a City of Hope,” Hahn said as our tour concluded, “I hope that you can help us get there.” Events such as the tour are shining examples of what Metro/Detroiters can do when focused on the welfare of their communities.  To prove this, next year’s tour will undoubtedly be even bigger, and the prospect of ensuring food security of more importance in this transitional period.  It is rumored that Shed 2 of Eastern Market, now currently closed, will become a home to local gardeners only; and, more exciting, an actual garden plot placed inside.  It is through continued innovations such as this that farming in the city will become a reality expressed in the improvement of public health, the establishment of economic and environmental sustainability, and in the continued efforts of the revitalization of divine Detroit.

The tour was an inspiring glimpse into the future and a particular joy to me, as I will soon be trying my luck in the D in a few short months.  As Jackie Victor, co-owner of Avalon Bakery in the Cass Corridor, wrote to me in an e-mail following the tour, “I really feel like we are part of an evolving social movement. It is a very thrilling time to live in Detroit.”

Profile
 
 
   
1 of 3
1